Please read this scenario prior to answering the question
You are employed as an Enterprise Architect in a team at a large company. The
company sells luxury food and drinks in more than 10,000 stores worldwide. The
company is a leader in using technology to connect with its customers. This includes
online ordering, mobile apps, and rewards programs. The company is also famous for
bringing new ideas to the market, like ordering through apps, using Al to suggest
personalized options, self-service pickup stations, and changing prices based on
demand.
The stores are open every day. They send timely sales data to a central system that
manages inventory. This system can predict what products are needed, adjust how
much stock there is, and order more stock automatically. The stores and the main
inventory system work directly with the mobile apps, allowing orders to be made
online. The central inventory system is located at the company's main data center.
The company will merge with a major competitor. This competitor has a synergistic
business. Leaders from both companies have told shareholders that the merger will
happen fast. There will be minimal impact for customers. All stores will keep the
current brand names. They will combine their systems, choosing the best ones to use.
This means their store management and back-office systems will become one. They
will stop using duplicate systems and use one main system to manage the stores.
They will also cut down on the number of back-office applications they use.
The Request for Architecture Work to oversee the merger has been approved.
Stakeholders, concerns, and business requirements have been identified. The
stakeholders have made it clear that they expect to continue to be able to innovate
quickly, and that changes should not restrict that capability. The scope of what is
inside and what is outside the architecture efforts has been confirmed. The next step
is to revisit and review the Architecture Principles, as they form part of the constraints
on architecture work.
Business Continuity is essential given that the business depends on real-time
ordering and automated inventory management. During the systems integration,
maintaining service for customers and inventory operations must be prioritized
Refer to the scenario
You have been asked to identify the most relevant Architecture Principles for the
merger besides Business Continuity.
Based on the TOGAF standard, which of the following is the best answer?
[Note: You should assume that the company follows the example set of Architecture
Principles provided in the TOGAF standard, ADM Techniques, Architecture Principles
chapter.]
Answer : D
You are asked to identify the most relevant Architecture Principles, besides Business Continuity, that apply to a rapid merger, where:
Back-office and store management systems will be consolidated
Duplicate applications will be eliminated
Innovation must remain fast
Customer experience must remain uninterrupted
Combined enterprise value is the priority
TOGAF's example Architecture Principles include four main categories:
Business Principles
Data Principles
Application Principles
Technology Principles
Option D contains the principles that best support the specific needs of the merger as described.
Why Option D is correct
1. Service Orientation (Business Principle)
This principle states that architecture should be organized around services, enabling flexibility, loose coupling, and ease of integration. For the merger:
Integrating two companies' store systems, mobile apps, and inventory platforms requires modular, interoperable services.
Service orientation directly supports the requirement that innovation must not slow down.
It allows systems to be merged with minimal disruption.
This principle supports fast integration + ongoing innovation --- exactly what stakeholders demand.
2. Maximize Benefit to the Enterprise (Business Principle)
This principle ensures decisions are made from an enterprise-wide (not departmental or local) perspective.
In the scenario:
Two companies are merging.
Decisions must prioritize combined enterprise value, not local optimizations by either company.
System consolidation and elimination of duplicates requires an enterprise-first mindset.
This principle aligns perfectly with a merger that aims to unify operations and reduce redundancy.
3. Common Use Applications (Application Principle)
This is one of the MOST relevant principles in any merger.
TOGAF defines this principle as:
''Applications should be shared across the enterprise and not duplicated.''
In the scenario:
Back-office systems and store management tools must be consolidated.
Duplicate applications are explicitly to be reduced.
One main system will be used across stores.
This principle directly matches the merger's objectives.
Summary
Option D contains the three principles that best support:
A major merger
System consolidation
Reduction of duplication
Enterprise-wide benefit
Flexible, service-oriented integration
Continued innovation
Therefore, Option D is the most appropriate selection according to TOGAF's example Architecture Principles.